Captain Willis

4.6
(95 votes)
34V5+973, 34100 Utila, Bay Islands
Closed now • Opens at 12:00

Contact

Discover the Delightful Dining Experience at Captain Willis

Located in the heart of Utila, Bay Islands, Captain Willis offers an exceptional dining experience that combines fresh, flavorful seafood with a relaxed island vibe. Visitors praise the restaurant for its incredible seafood dishes crafted from some of the freshest ingredients around. Beyond seafood lovers, vegetarians will also find thoughtfully prepared options that go beyond standard fare, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied.

Atmosphere and Service

The ambiance at Captain Willis captures the best of island life, featuring great music and a chill, welcoming energy that makes every visit memorable. The indoor seating is cozy and basic, with a closed exterior door design that minimizes the chance of sand flea bites, enhancing guest comfort. Friendly and attentive service is consistently highlighted by patrons, adding a personal touch to the whole dining experience.

With a relatively small setting and only a few tables available, making a reservation is advised to secure your spot. The menu may be limited in number but excels in quality, with popular dishes such as spring rolls and fish and chips often recommended by guests. To top off your meal, the spicy margarita comes highly recommended, delivering a perfect flavor balance to complement the cuisine.

Open both midday and evening on most days, Captain Willis offers flexible dining times to suit your schedule. Whether you’re seeking a casual lunch or a relaxed dinner, this gem on Utila Island is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts looking to enjoy island freshness and friendly vibes.

4.6
95 votes
5
75
4
9
3
8
2
1
1
2
dl rdr
July 2, 2025
one of the best restaurants in utila and the boho night is incredible, highly recommended!
Daniella Ortez
July 1, 2025
Incredible seafood, worth every minute of the wait. Super fresh, full of flavor, and the vibe is unbeatable, great music, and chill island energy. They also cater to vegetarians with solid options, not just filler. Friendly service, amazing food. A must if you’re on the island!
Sofía Cabrera
June 29, 2025
One of the best on the island!
Aude Robinson
June 20, 2025
Delicious food and I will definitely be back. The staff constantly touching hair and sometimes dog without washing hands was a little concerning. But overall a great dinner spot.
Kristian F.
June 19, 2025
Best place on the island for 10/10 food. A place you can‘t miss!